Mindset Matters - find inspiration to see money in a calmer, more empowering way.
Last month we introduced the bucket framework. Three pools of money, each with a different job, organized by when the money will actually be needed.
This month we go deeper into Bucket One. Not because it is the most exciting! Because it’s the most important one to get right.
Bucket One covers real expenses coming in the next 1-3 years. Its job never changes. What changes is what fills it, and how hard life makes it to fund.
Here is the context that makes this urgent. The current US personal savings rate is 4.5%. The long-run historical average is 8.4%. Most Americans are already operating at less than half the savings rate that was once considered normal.
That gap doesn’t show up as a crisis right away. It shows up quietly, over time, as a Bucket One that is never quite full enough when life needs it to be.
List every expense greater than $500 you can reasonably anticipate in the next 1-3 years. Not a budget. Just a list.
A car. The roof that needs attention. The medical appointment you keep rescheduling. A trip you’ve been promising yourself.
That list is your Bucket One. Once you can see it, you can start building toward it with intention instead of hoping nothing goes wrong.
Bucket One has the same job at every stage of life. Cover what is coming in the next 1-3 years without touching anything else. Life stages change the conversation around it significantly:
Ages 18 to 30. Lower fixed costs, fewer dependents, often the ability to live at home or split expenses. A 20-30% percent savings rate is genuinely achievable here. Not easy. Achievable. The moment a car payment, rent, a relationship, or a child enters the picture, that rate compresses almost automatically. Most people don’t decide to save less. Life just fills the space.
Ages 45 to 60. More income in many cases, but more pulling at it. Mortgage. Kids. Aging parents. Home maintenance. A second car. Medical costs. A realistic savings rate at this stage may be 10-15%. That’s not failure. That’s life.
The purpose of Bucket One evolves too. In your twenties it’s a few thousand dollars for a trip to Europe or a first apartment. By your forties it’s six months to a year of living expenses, the difference between a job loss becoming a crisis or an inconvenience you can weather.
Same bucket. Completely different meaning.
Workers without adequate short-term savings are 13 times more likely to take a hardship withdrawal from their 401k. But that’s usually not the first mistake. The first one happens at the checkout screen. When Bucket One runs dry, most people reach for a credit-card first. Consumer debt at 20-25% interest is one of the hardest holes to climb out of. Then comes the retirement account. The tax penalties are significant. The lost compounding is permanent. A Bucket One problem quietly becomes a Bucket Three catastrophe.
When I landed my first serious job in the early 2000s, my savings sat in a regular bank savings-account earning less than 0.25%. I was doing the right behavior in the wrong environment. High yield savings accounts (HYSAs) have changed that. But HYSAs are not the only option. Certificates of Deposit (CDs) lock your money for a defined period in exchange for a slightly higher rate. Treasury Bills (T-Bills) offer competitive rates with the highest possible credit safety. Money Market Funds offer liquidity with rates close to a HYSA. None of these are investments. They are places for Bucket One money to wait and hold its value until you need it.
One more thing, keep your Bucket One account separate from your checking account, at a different bank if possible. The small friction of transferring money across institutions is often enough to stop an impulse decision. Out of easy reach matters more than people think.
"Living within your means" sounds like a cliche. I still train myself on this every day. Marcus Aurelius was writing the same reminder two thousand years ago, asking whether what he was about to do was actually necessary. The struggle has not changed. Neither has the solution. "Because most of what we say and do is not essential. Ask yourself at every moment, is this necessary?" (Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, 4.24)